Fuels and engines

91, 95 or 98: is premium petrol worth the money?

What octane actually measures, which cars need premium, what it costs over a year, and what changed when Australia tightened its petrol standard.

Published 15 November 2026 · 5 minute read · By Safal Aryal, MechAxis co-founder

01

The short answer

Use the minimum octane your manufacturer specifies, which is printed inside the fuel flap and in the owner's manual. If the car is designed for 91, paying for 95 or 98 is unlikely to give you anything you can measure. If the car requires 95 or 98, using less is a false economy. Few motoring topics stir up more argument than this. One r/CarsAustralia thread urging people to stop putting 95 and 98 in cars that do not need it passed 660 comments, and 'Unleaded 98 or 91' and 'Fuel 91 vs 98' each drew more than a hundred.

02

What the number measures

The RON figure is an octane rating, and CarExpert describes it simply as a measure of the petrol's resistance to burning. It is not a measure of energy, cleanliness or quality. High-compression and turbocharged engines squeeze the fuel and air mixture harder, and a low-octane fuel can ignite too early under that pressure. This is engine knock. Higher octane resists it. An engine designed for 91 does not create the conditions that need 98's extra resistance, so the more expensive fuel has nothing extra to do. In Australia the usual choices are 91, E10 at 94, 95 and 98.

03

Cars that say 95 or 98

If the fuel flap says premium unleaded only, or gives a minimum of 95 or 98, treat it as a requirement. CarExpert notes that putting 91 or 95 in a car designed for 98 can lead to engine knock. Modern engines have knock sensors that protect the engine by pulling back ignition timing, but that costs power and economy, and the protection is meant for the occasional bad tank rather than permanent use. Some manuals say a higher grade is recommended while a lower one is acceptable. In that case you can use the lower grade and accept slightly less performance.

04

Does premium improve economy or performance in a 91 car?

Sometimes slightly, usually not enough to pay for itself. Some engines rated for 91 can advance their timing a little on higher octane. CarExpert tested a Ford Ranger Raptor, which is rated to run on 91 or higher, at a proving ground and recorded 0 to 100 km/h in 5.72 seconds on 98 against 6.44 seconds on 91. A twin-turbo performance engine is where you would expect to find a gain. In an ordinary commuter car designed for 91, any improvement in fuel use is generally smaller than the price difference, and Canstar's summary is blunt: unless the manufacturer requires premium, it is probably a waste of money.

05

What it costs over a year

Here is an illustrative example, not a quote. The last ABS survey put average travel at about 12,100 km a year. At 8 litres per 100 km that is 968 litres. If 98 costs 25 cents a litre more than 91 where you fill up, the difference is about $242 a year. Replace those inputs with your own distance, consumption and the price gap on the day. For scale, the NRMA reported the national average for regular unleaded at 222.8 cents a litre in mid-November 2026, after a volatile year for fuel prices. The gap between grades varies widely between stations.

06

The 'premium is cleaner' argument has changed

For years one real difference was sulfur. Regular 91 was allowed far more of it than premium. Australia's petrol standard changed on 15 December 2025, and all grades of petrol are now limited to a maximum of 10 parts per million of sulfur. That removes most of the old cleanliness argument for buying 98 in a car that does not need it. Fuel companies also promote the detergent additives in their premium fuels. Those may help keep injectors clean, but the benefit is hard to verify independently, and regular servicing matters far more to engine health.

07

A simple rule, and when to ask

Read the fuel flap. Use at least that grade. Do not pay for more unless the manual says the engine benefits and you value the difference. If a car designed for 91 pings, hesitates or runs poorly, higher octane might mask the symptom, but the cause is usually something a workshop should look at, such as carbon build-up, a sensor or a cooling problem. Workshops that use MechAxis keep each vehicle's history and notes together, so a recurring complaint like this can be tracked across visits instead of being treated as new each time.

Sources

Common questions

01Will 98 damage a car designed for 91?+

No. It will not harm the engine. It just costs more for little or no benefit in most cars designed for 91.

02Can I put 91 in a car that requires 95?+

Avoid it. The engine may knock or reduce power to protect itself. If it happens once by mistake, drive gently and refill with the correct grade as soon as practical.

03Is 95 a good middle option?+

Only if your car specifies 95 or the manual says it benefits. Otherwise it is the same question as 98: more money without a matching gain.

04Does premium fuel clean the engine?+

Premium fuels are marketed with extra detergents, and since December 2025 all Australian petrol grades share the same low sulfur limit. For a car in good condition, on-time servicing does more than fuel choice.

Run a workshop?

MechAxis keeps bookings, inspections, quotes and each vehicle's service history in one place, so your customers get clear answers like these. Try it free for 30 days.

Start free trial